Monday, April 08, 2013

My latest comment on George R. R. Martin - A Game of Thrones - also left in Kanlaon Blog -

Whoa - Game of Thrones - I have read books 1 through 5 - I guess the scenes you describe are in HBO version - the poor girl in armor is Brienne - the boy who fell is Bran Stark, yes, Joffrey and the Margeary gal are one dimensional - Tywin Lannister "shits gold."

In the books, the characters are quite multidimensional - books 1-3 are the best - I read my eyes out too.  But #4 is padded and #5 too - George R.R. Martin has a penchant for killing off your faves, so be warned. 

I am correct in that I decided not to watch the TV - one reason, I have no TV :) and the other, I have already formed an image of the characters in my head, and I can't relate to their too real !! TV representations - in the fiction, the books, they are more real to me -

Great argument for reading rather than watching (TV)

The dragons, I guess the TV version has not got to them yet? -- They are overused in Western fantasies.  GRRM uses all the tricks in the book to make them real, but they only get real when they get uncontrollable - I think they are best viewed as a metaphor for the arms race.

This reviewer in Slate likes latest Murakami novel--the walled city--the walled garden.

https://slate.com/culture/2024/11/haruki-murakami-book-city-uncertain-walls-severance-review.html