Which ones to buy and read--(consider your own book budget)--Alamut novels

AI Overview The preference between James Boschert and Judith Tarr for their respective "Alamut" novels is subjective, as they offer different takes on the subject matter .

Judith Tarr's Alamut series is a work of historical fantasy and includes elements of magic. Her novel features a half-elven prince and an immortal assassin, blending medieval history with a compelling fantasy storyline and high romance. It's recommended for readers who enjoy a mix of historical detail and speculative, fantastical elements.

James Boschert's Assassins of Alamut is a work of historical fiction. It is noted for being "incredibly researched" and focuses more heavily on historical accuracy, detail (including food and everyday life), and realistic adventure rather than magic. It is recommended for readers who prefer a more grounded, historical narrative.

Vladimir Bartol also wrote a famous, highly influential novel simply titled Alamut, which is an allegorical historical novel that became a post-9/11 bestseller and explores political manipulation of religious devotion. Ultimately, the "better" author depends entirely on whether the reader prefers a fantasy (Tarr) or realistic historical fiction (Boschert) approach to the setting and the legend of the Assassins.